31+Compare+and+Contrast+Essay

=PARAGRAPH 1= "The Devil's Arithmetic" is a novel and movie. It is about a girl Hannah who travels to 1942 by opening the door to Elijah. Hannah meets new people and needs to help her friends in the camps. As she helps them she does something else no one else would probally do. As Hannah tries to remember and fights to live everyday she does the unthinkable. =PARAGRAPH 2= The novel for "The Devil's Arithmetic" had Aaron as Hannah's sister in it. When Hannah opened the door for Elijah she met Shmuel a farmer in the story. Hannah is related to aunt Eva but not Rivka. Shmuel doesn't get married at all in the novel. When the trucks came to pick up the Jews the general let them choose if they wanted to stay or leave very friendly. A three fingered women was in charge of the newcomers at the camp. As Hannah's hair was cut of she forgot about her past in the 2000s with her family. At Shmuel's wedding Hannah meets Esther and Shifre and Hannah finds them at the camps. While Hannah was in line for dinner she met a girl named Rivka who lost all her family besides her brother but he didn't feel like a brother to her. Hannah, Shifre, Esther and Rivka work in the kitchen together at the camp. One day, while working Hannah tells Shifre, Esther, and Rivka a story about herself when a new Nazi picks Shifre, Esther, and Rivka to go to Lilith's cave a gas chamber but Hannah takes Rivka's headband and puts it on and as she walks to the gas chamber right when she opens the door she comes back to her families seder and no time has past. =PARAGRAPH 3= However, the movie for "The Devil's Arithmetic" is different because Aaron isn't Hannah's sister or a character. When Hannah opened the door for Elijah she wakes up in a bed and meets Gitl and Rivka, and Rivka was her cousin. Shmuel does get married but the Nazi's came and forced the Jews into a truck without a reason why and they never discussed it. The three fingered lady wasn't in control it was the Nazi commandant. Hannah does not loose her memory throughout the entire story. Hannah never finds Shifre and Esther but only Rivka. Instead of working in the Kitchen, Rivka and Hannah work out on the fields. Instead of Hannah telling a story Rivka coughs and is picked but Hannah takes Rivka's bandanna and puts it on and acts like she's coughing and saves Rivka's life. Hannah dies in the movie then wakes up in a bed and she got drunk on the wine she drank. =PARAGRAPH 4= I think the novel of "The Devil's Arithmetic" is better than the movie because their are entirely different scenes in the movie. Some characters aren't even mentioned in the movie. Some characters were introduced strangely in the movie. The novel made more sense and didn't seem to be missing anything at all and everything was introduced at a good time.